| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| uwittehh |
Posted - Apr 26 2008 : 4:08:18 PM
Yes! I have it :-))
Today this very nice Kiev with Ukrainian Logo arrived here. It's fully working, even the meter works fine, looks not often used and has a really really nice box with it:
As I know there have only seen 2 of such boxes. It's nice, big, good made and has silk inside. Amazing.
Ulrich
|
| 15 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| fedka |
Posted - Apr 27 2008 : 6:14:30 PM
Well, Maizenberg lived in Kiev, and the book was published in Kiev, so maybe the editor decided to have some fun. Probably eventually this cost him his job and maybe freedom:-(
|
| fedka |
Posted - Apr 27 2008 : 6:03:01 PM
Aidas,
I think the Maizenberg book pictures are not related to this discussion. I pulled my books and checked them - in 1961 they show a Kiev that probably never existed - a Kiev II with a Kyiv in Ukraininan only (p. 281), in block letters. I am not aware of such markings, and this looks like a typo or even a joke, which was discovered by a sharp censor and corrected by the 3dr edition.
Or, perhaps such logo did exist?
Yuri
http://www.ussrphoto.com/UserContent/kyiv2_maizenberg.jpg
quote:
Originally posted by AidasCams
... and one more interesting fact about Ukrainian Kiev. I suppose almost all have ever seen I.Maizenberg book "Camera Structure and Repair", issued in 1961, 1962 and 1964 in KIEV.
At first 2 issues I have found a picture of KIEV II camera with Ukrainian engravings indeed! At the last issue of 1964 (my special thanks to Jim for this great book!), Kiev II Ukrainian is already replaced with ordinary one ...  Few versions about this: either Kiev II Ukrainian camera have never existed, so was replaced with real one, or Ukrainian engravings were prohibited by Soviet Authorities ...
|
| Michel |
Posted - Apr 27 2008 : 5:07:58 PM
Hi Ulrich,
Many congratulations for this marvel. 
Best regards,
Michel. |
| AidasCams |
Posted - Apr 27 2008 : 2:57:04 PM
... and one more interesting fact about Ukrainian Kiev. I suppose almost all have ever seen I.Maizenberg book "Camera Structure and Repair", issued in 1961, 1962 and 1964 in KIEV.
At first 2 issues I have found a picture of KIEV II camera with Ukrainian engravings indeed! At the last issue of 1964 (my special thanks to Jim for this great book!), Kiev II Ukrainian is already replaced with ordinary one ... Few versions about this: either Kiev II Ukrainian camera have never existed, so was replaced with real one, or Ukrainian engravings were prohibited by Soviet Authorities ... |
| AidasCams |
Posted - Apr 27 2008 : 2:43:22 PM
Ulrich,
Great find - my best congratulations! Although I have some suspicious, that Commemorative box (1957) + Kiev with Ukrainian engravings (1958) = 40th Anniversary of Ukrainian SSR (1957), your complete set looks really great!
Best Regards,
Aidas |
| uwittehh |
Posted - Apr 27 2008 : 02:02:58 AM
I have changed my first post and have made some better pics today in the morning.
Guido, very nice work, as all your articles :-)
Ulrich
http://fotos.cconin.de |
| fedka |
Posted - Apr 26 2008 : 11:56:19 PM
This is a great article, and auto translations work pretty well too.
If Kyiv engraving was indeed a commemoration, it is a very neat one.
Maybe someone already solved the mystery of A and B serial numbers on the Kiev III?
Yuri |
| Guido |
Posted - Apr 26 2008 : 11:41:47 PM
Dear friends
An article about this "Kiiv" from the seller of this item and author of the book "Zenit", Dr. Alexander Schulz, you can find here:
http://www.g-st.ch/privat/kameras/jubilaeumskiiv.html
As allways on my homepage this article is written in german (please use your prefered online translater). This article was first published in "Photographica Cabinett" in 2005.
Best wishes - Guido
|
| Vlad |
Posted - Apr 26 2008 : 11:37:57 PM
True, only a theory, but box is not so subtle .. Remember, there are a few other cameras where commemoration only occurs on the box and not on the camera itself.. in this case it's a slight change on camera, very possible in my opinion... 1957 on the box does not really mean it was made in 1957, it may have been 1958, who knows, maybe they released commemorative models in 1958 and just put the 1957 date on the box match the holiday...
Vlad |
| fedka |
Posted - Apr 26 2008 : 11:29:49 PM
This is a good theory, but only a theory. I do not have such high confidence. This box is clearly a commemorative item, with a 1957 date on it. The Kiev-IIIa is a 1958 camera with a Kyiv engraving. can be a co-incidence, why not?
Engraving Kyiv in Ukrainian is a very subtle and elegant commemoration, and the Soviets were never subtle when it came to politics and propaganda. Think of all other commemorative engravings - all clearly written with Soviet symbols, quite in-your-face.
You know, I am always on a skeptical side:-)
|
| Vlad |
Posted - Apr 26 2008 : 11:07:51 PM
Possible, but it makes perfect sense though, the box explains everything if you think about it! |
| fedka |
Posted - Apr 26 2008 : 10:35:58 PM
The box is beautiful.
But Vlad, all "Ukrainian" Kievs we know (Aidas has a list of them) were made in 1958, and even in 1959. This box clearly calls for 1957.
And I see that that the lens is 58xx, so the body is probably 1958 too.
Perhaps the started shipping this 1957 box in 1958? maybe it took Ukrainian Communist Party a year to clear such commemoration with Moscow?:-) |
| Vlad |
Posted - Apr 26 2008 : 9:50:00 PM
I think now we have one mystery solved!! Ukranian Kievs were made for 40th Anniversary of Soviet Ukraine! Bill, as you kept telling me - boxes are everything!!!
Ulrich, thank you for putting one mystery to rest!
Vlad. |
| nightphoto |
Posted - Apr 26 2008 : 9:17:01 PM
Very fine Ulrich! Thanks for showing us!
Regards, Bill
|
| okynek |
Posted - Apr 26 2008 : 7:06:52 PM
Amazing indid !!! Thank you for posting it!
Would be nice to have this in wiki  |
